Achieving Success in Postsecondary Education: The Facts About Student Debt

June 2017

The story of a generation drowning in debt is misleading for a number of reasons. This report looks at the landscape of student debt in the U.S. as well as trends and innovative approaches in private funding of higher education.

Summary

This paper reviews data about student borrowing, as well as the variation in debt levels associated with students with different characteristics and different educational histories. This information, along with evidence about the factors associated with repayment difficulties, points to policy solutions such as efforts to diminish problematic borrowing and an improved income-driven repayment system.

This work was discussed during a convening co-hosted by the TIAA Institute and Rockefeller Philanthropy Advisors: Postsecondary Success, Debt, and Philanthropy’s Role.

Key Insights
There is a positive impact of postsecondary education on employment and earnings.
Relatively high-earning households carry a disproportionate amount of student debt.
A significant share of the difficulties related to student loan repayment arises from failure to complete degrees and from poor labor market outcomes for some types of degrees/credentials.
A system that both prepares and protects people seeking to pursue higher education should be high on the policy agenda.
Methodology

To understand student debt, Rockefeller Philanthropy Advisors reviewed existing research and data about student borrowing in the United States and characteristics of borrowers.

The typical borrower struggling with student debt is not the 22-year-old recent bachelor’s degree recipient frequently pictured in news coverage.
Download Report Materials
Authors

About TIAA Institute

The TIAA Institute helps advance the ways individuals and institutions plan for financial security and organizational effectiveness. The Institute conducts in depth research, provides access to a network of thought leaders, and enables those it serves to anticipate trends, plan future strategies and maximize opportunities for success.
Related Publications

Related Publications

Design thinking

Design for equity in higher education

June 2021

Liberatory design thinking—a way to address equity challenges and change efforts in complex systems—can help campus leaders rethink policy and practices for non-tenure-track faculty.

Zoomed-in rendering

Employment volatility in the academic workforce: Implications for faculty financial and retirement plans

June 2021

Short-term appointments in the academic workforce account for roughly two thirds of all faculty positions. Yet little is known about this segment’s financial needs, experiences and professional stability.

APLU_June2021

Addressing student need beyond crisis management

June 2021

Many higher education leaders believe any student should be able to attend any university without taking on unmanageable debt. Demographic trends suggest reaching this goal will be challenging.