Cost Savings or Cost Shifting? The Relationship between Part-Time Contingent Faculty and Institutional Spending

November 2016
Related Topics
Contingent Workers

While reliance on part-time contingent faculty has helped constrain faculty compensation costs, it hasn’t produced the same level of savings in total compensation costs for all employees.

Summary

Colleges and universities across the board are relying more on contingent faculty to increase flexibility and reduce costs. Yet little is known about whether such savings actually lower overall institutional costs or if the money saved on instruction is being spent elsewhere. This paper, the second in a two-part series based on data provided by the Delta Cost Project at American Institutes for Research, examines the financial trade-offs institutions make when hiring more part-time contingent faculty.

Key Insights
A clear relationship exists between reliance on part-time contingent faculty and cost savings in faculty salaries and benefits. However, savings in total compensation costs for all employees during the period studied (2003 to 2013) have been more modest.
Public four-year institutions are apt to use savings associated with part-time contingent faculty to increase expenditures on administration and maintenance.
Private four-year and public two-year institutions showed little sign of cost shifting, reporting not only flat or declining instructional spending but also limited growth or declines in administration and maintenance expenditures.
Methodology

The information used in this study comes from the Delta Cost Project Database, 1987–2013, which includes data reported by institutions to the U.S. Department of Education’s Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System. These data have been harmonized (when possible) to account for survey changes over time. Staffing data from the 2002 Fall Employees by Assigned Position Survey (i.e., 2002–03 school year, or 2003 academic year) were appended to the Delta Cost Project Database to provide more detailed staffing information. The study focuses primarily on the 2012–13 academic year, with select analyses examining the 10-year period from 2003 to 2013.

Higher education is a labor-intensive industry, which makes shifting to contingent faculty a natural cost-saving measure.
Download Report Materials
Authors

About TIAA Institute

The TIAA Institute helps advance the ways individuals and institutions plan for financial security and organizational effectiveness. The Institute conducts in depth research, provides access to a network of thought leaders, and enables those it serves to anticipate trends, plan future strategies and maximize opportunities for success.
Related Publications

Related Publications

Hutchinson Financial Communications June 2017 Promo Image

Financial Communications and Asset Allocation Decisions

Financial communications can be complex, making misinterpretation likely. This study takes an in-depth look at how people process – and act upon – financial information.

Goda Distributions from Retirement Accounts June 2017 Promo Image

How Do Distributions from Retirement Accounts Respond to Early Withdrawal Penalties?

To preserve retirement wealth, IRAs and employer-sponsored defined contribution plans typically impose a penalty on early withdrawals. How might individuals respond if the penalty were lifted?

ACE ACPS 2017 Photo

American College President Study 2017

As market forces continue to reshape the higher education landscape, understanding the U.S. college presidency – and its inherent challenges and opportunities – is more important than ever.