Organic Benchmarks for University Endowments

March 2017

Can a university’s characteristics be a better indicator of an endowment’s effectiveness than endowment size? 

Summary

Organic benchmarks based on university characteristics – such as tuition discounts, per-student endowment, endowment payments to university budget, and total student enrollment – can be telling measures of endowment effectiveness. By comparing university goals with the use of endowment assets, this study shows that endowment size alone does not sufficiently measure endowment asset performance.

Key Insights
Organic benchmarks need to reflect the areas a university seeks to improve the most using endowment assets.
Endowment size is just as ambiguous as organic benchmarks in evaluating how effectively endowment assets are being employed.
Organic benchmark results should be compared only among universities similar enough to make legitimate comparisons.
Methodology

The author examined endowment performance at 898 universities between 2002 and 2014. Using data from NACUBO and the National Center for Education Statistics, he separated the universities into three groups based on endowment size and university characteristics to measure how effectively universities manage their endowment assets.

Larger endowments experience more growth when employing organic benchmarks.
Download Report Materials
Authors

About TIAA Institute

The TIAA Institute helps advance the ways individuals and institutions plan for financial security and organizational effectiveness. The Institute conducts in depth research, provides access to a network of thought leaders, and enables those it serves to anticipate trends, plan future strategies and maximize opportunities for success.
Related Publications

Related Publications

ACE ACPS 2017 Photo

American College President Study 2017

As market forces continue to reshape the higher education landscape, understanding the U.S. college presidency – and its inherent challenges and opportunities – is more important than ever.

The Facts About Student Debt_June 2017

Achieving Success in Postsecondary Education: The Facts About Student Debt

The story of a generation drowning in debt is misleading for a number of reasons. This report looks at the landscape of student debt in the U.S. as well as trends and innovative approaches in private funding of higher education.

RPA - TIAA Institute Trends in Philanthropy June 2017

Achieving Success in Postsecondary Education: Trends in Philanthropy

Over the past decade, foundations and other entities awarding higher education grants have shifted their focus toward programs that encourage student retention and graduation, particularly for low-income and first-generation college students.